Straight from the pantry
What Can I Make with Cheddar?
Cheddar is a sharp, golden cheese that most families keep on hand. These recipes make the most of its bold flavor and easy melt.
Filters (2)
14 recipes match your filters
Cooking with cheddar
Cheddar is a firm cow's milk cheese. It is aged for a while, and the longer it ages, the sharper and more crumbly it gets. Mild cheddar is smooth and soft. Sharp cheddar has a stronger bite.
Compared with its cheese cousins, cheddar sits in the middle. It is firmer than mozzarella and milder than Parmesan. It melts nicely for sauces, toasties, and casseroles, and it is not as salty as feta.
Questions folks ask
What can I make with cheddar?
Try mac and cheese, grilled cheese, potato bakes, broccoli soup, quesadillas, and cheesy biscuits.
Does cheddar melt well?
Yes. Younger cheddar melts the smoothest. Very aged cheddar can be a bit grainy, so melt it gently.
Is orange cheddar different from white?
The color usually comes from a natural coloring added to the cheese. The taste is mostly the same. Age matters more for flavor.
Kitchen tips
- Use sharp cheddar when you want the cheese flavor to stand out.
- Grate it fresh for sauces so they stay smooth.
- Melt it over low heat. High heat can make it split and turn oily.
- Mix mild and sharp cheddar for a good balance in baked dishes.